PA CROP Services vs Incfile
Incfile (now part of Tailor Brands) built its reputation on low-cost business formation and a compelling “free first year of registered agent service” offer for new LLCs and corporations. For business owners forming a new PA entity, the free registered agent year is genuinely useful. The question is what happens after year one — and whether the service continues to meet Pennsylvania’s specific compliance requirements as those requirements get more demanding.
With the 2027 annual report enforcement deadline approaching, evaluating your registered office provider against PA-specific criteria — not just general registered agent capabilities — has become a practical necessity.
Quick Comparison: The Numbers
| Feature | Incfile (Tailor Brands) | PA CROP Services |
|---|---|---|
| Annual registered office price | Free year 1; $119/year after | $99/year from day one |
| PA CROP license (15 Pa. C.S. § 109) | Not held | Yes — DOS #0015295203 |
| PA annual report filing | Add-on, $100+ | Included on Pro ($349) and Empire ($699) |
| Same-day document scanning | Basic scanning | Yes — all plans |
| Compliance portal | Simple dashboard | Full compliance dashboard |
| PA 2027 deadline tracking | Generic multi-state alerts | PA entity-type-specific reminders |
| PA DOS expertise | Generalist (50 states) | Pennsylvania only |
| Physical PA office address | Virtual address network | Real commercial office, Erie, PA |
| Business formation service | Yes — primary offering | No (referrals to PA attorneys) |
| Hosting, SSL, email included | Not included in RA service | Business Starter plan ($199/yr) |
About Incfile / Tailor Brands
Incfile was acquired by Tailor Brands in 2022 and now operates as part of a broader business formation and branding platform. Their strength is in helping entrepreneurs form LLCs and corporations quickly and affordably. They handle formation filings in all 50 states and bundle registered agent service into their formation packages.
Their registered agent service is straightforward: they provide a state address for registered agent purposes in each state where you need one, receive and forward documents, and maintain an online portal for document access. For a newly formed PA business needing the basics, Incfile’s first-year bundle is a reasonable starting point.
The “Free” Year: What to Know Before Renewal
Incfile’s free first year of registered agent service is a genuinely useful onboarding offer when you form through them. After the first year, the service auto-renews at $119/year. PA CROP Services charges $99/year from the start. For businesses that formed through Incfile and are approaching their renewal date:
- PA CROP Services saves you $20/year ($119 vs $99 for basic registered office)
- PA CROP Services is a licensed PA CROP under 15 Pa. C.S. § 109; Incfile is not
- Switching costs $5 (DSCB:15-108 filing fee at file.dos.pa.gov)
- The switch takes 7–10 business days to process
Many Incfile clients switch to a PA CROP at their first renewal specifically to get PA-specific annual report management before the 2027 enforcement window closes.
Where Incfile Has a Clear Advantage
- Free first year of registered agent: For a brand new PA LLC, the free year reduces formation costs meaningfully.
- Integrated formation + registered agent: If you are forming your entity now, having formation and registered agent from one provider simplifies setup.
- Simple, streamlined experience: Incfile’s formation process is designed for first-time filers and is genuinely easy to use.
- Branding tools: The Tailor Brands integration provides logo design, brand identity tools, and website builders that PA CROP Services does not offer.
Where PA CROP Services Has a Clear Advantage
- Licensed PA CROP: PA CROP Services holds a PA CROP license under 15 Pa. C.S. § 109 (DOS #0015295203). Incfile does not. See why the CROP license matters.
- Lower ongoing cost: $99/year vs $119/year after Incfile’s free period.
- Annual report filing included: Business Pro ($349/year) includes PA annual report filing. Incfile charges $100+ as an add-on. Over three years, PA CROP Services Business Pro at $349/year comes to $1,047 including annual report filing; Incfile at $119/year registered agent plus $100+/year annual report filing comes to $657+, but without the licensed CROP status, PA-specific expertise, or same-day document handling.
- Real physical PA address: Our office is at 924 W 23rd St, Erie, PA — a staffed commercial location. Incfile uses a virtual address network for PA.
- 2027 deadline specificity: PA CROP Services tracks your entity’s specific deadline (LLC = September 30, corporation = June 30) and sends reminders timed to your type. Incfile’s compliance calendar is generalist.
The 2027 Deadline and Why Formation Providers Often Miss It
Incfile’s core business is formation — helping you create a new entity. Annual report compliance is a downstream service they have added to their portfolio. When Pennsylvania introduced Act 122 of 2022 with its new annual report requirements (effective 2025, enforcement 2027), providers with a formation-first mindset were slower to develop PA-specific compliance workflows than providers whose entire business model is built around ongoing PA compliance.
The 2027 enforcement deadline creates a binary outcome: entities either file by their deadline, or they face administrative dissolution (domestic entities) or permanent termination (foreign entities). A provider who sends you a generic “annual report season is coming” email is fundamentally different from one who knows your LLC’s September 30 deadline and sends reminders at 90, 60, 30, 14, and 7 days before it. Read the 2027 dissolution deadline analysis.
The Verdict
Incfile is a legitimate, functional registered agent service and an excellent formation platform for new businesses. The free first year is a genuine value for new PA LLCs. For ongoing compliance after year one — particularly with the 2027 enforcement deadline approaching — PA CROP Services offers a licensed PA CROP, lower renewal cost, included annual report filing, and PA-specific expertise that matters when the stakes are administrative dissolution.
The switch process is simple: sign up with PA CROP Services, file DSCB:15-108 at file.dos.pa.gov ($5 fee), and cancel your Incfile renewal before it charges. See the full switching guide.
PA CROP Services Plans
| Plan | Price | What’s Included |
|---|---|---|
| Compliance Only | $99/yr | Licensed registered office, same-day scanning, compliance portal |
| Business Starter | $199/yr | Above + annual report reminders, web hosting, SSL, email |
| Business Pro | $349/yr | Above + annual report filing, compliance alerts |
| Business Empire | $699/yr | Above + multi-entity management, priority support |
Frequently Asked Questions
Switch to a licensed PA CROP
Licensed PA CROP, same-day document handling, annual report filing included on Pro plan. From $99/year.
Compare plans →